Virgin Post

Well this is my virgin post.... well perhaps not exactly. I also blog under another pseudonym, and good luck to you if you can find it.

In essence, this blog is my candid view of the Singapore economy, and perhaps the world in general. I felt the need to produce a dichotomy of myself, one as a serious viewer of the economy and investments, and the other, a naughtier part of myself.

For today's post, I would like to pick on the article that was written on The Edge Singapore about 2 weeks back on the Singapore economy and the need to perhaps restructure the economy now rather than wait for another bubble or correction to happen.

The article (I shall have to come back with the title and the name of the author) rightly pointed out that the Singapore economy has not had it so good in the past 5-6 years, and may not see such good times perhaps for awhile.

All this while, the government has been harping on the ever growing divide between the have's and have not's and the sacred cow is that of some sort of welfare. This I will leave for another time.

The point I wanted to stress on was the point that much of the Singapore GDP is reliant on MNCs and GLCs and a few successful private enterprise. While GLCs are ever reliant to be anchored in Singapore, I can't say that much for MNCs. It is and will always be a business decision on whether to stay rooted in Singapore or to move to a lower cost country.

THe fallacy of the MNC approach and how it benefits the Singapore economy is that the MNC is, if you will, at the top of the food chain pyramid. In the second tier there are suppliers to these MNCs. Some of these will be MNCs themselves (ie, Applied Materials, KNS,etc) and some will be local players. Of late, we have been seeing the local suppliers having a good run on the SGX, like MMI and Jurong Tech, who supply to MNCs such as Seagate and Motorola.

What would happen if Seagate or Motorola were suddently up and relocation to another country? These companies would certainly have to move with them as their lifelines depend on the MNCs? And so what becomes of the Singapore economy? Jobs would naturally be lost and the impact would be felt on the lower income group people.

Instead, I think not enough attention has been put to develop our own companies that market to the world, instead of just to MNCs. These guys chase dollars whever the dollars may be. These guys bring Singapore's cutting edge to the world.

Prior to the bubble of 2000, there were dreams of making Singapore into another Silicon Valley with the TIF Venture FoF, etc etc. Lately it seems that it has all be quiet on this front. Even with the latest announcement by EDB on the Business Angels Scheme, I'm amazed at what is termed as business angels in this context.

THe manager of one such scheme has stated that he'd like to see some revenue as part of the consideration for investment. THen it defeats the purpose of angels as angels are people that entrepreneurs turn to when Venture Capitalists (VCs) fear to tread.

In Singapore, there is a lack of such risk taking angels, with most VCs preferring to invest in Series A or expansion stage companies. I know a friend who has tried to raise an early stage fund to no avail. There are some early stage VCs such as Upstream, but these are too few and far in between.

What is the use of spending all those billions of hard earned money on R&D where commercialization or future economic impact of these R&D projects are an afterthought? There are foreign VCs that specializes in helping technopreneurs develop their companies from such an early stage and I think there are opportunities for Singaporeans or locals to develop such a niche and prosper. But beware, it may take a few cycles of losing ones pants before striking it rich. And the investment value chain needs to be beefed up.

VCs tell me there is a dearth of good investible projects in Singapore, but as I see it, technopreneurs have a hard time getting into the radar scope of such VCs when they can't get access to early money.

TO be continued....